A U.S. district court judge agrees with the owner of II Portico restaurant, formerly in Center City Philadelphia and now in Burlington, New Jersey, that he didn’t infringe on the trademark of a restaurant with the same name located in New York.

The New York owner, Fife and Drum Inc., claimed in a 2017 suit that it registered the “Il Portico” name in Tappan, New York, in 1990 and alleged that defendant Delbello Enterprises later copied.