A New Jersey auto body shop owner’s plea that he was sucked into a contract of adhesion by Sherwin-Williams was in need of some polish, a federal judge has ruled in awarding the paint supplier $473,832 in damages.

U.S. District Judge Brian Martinotti of the District of New Jersey granted summary judgment to the Sherwin-Williams Co. in a case over a $554,000 supply contract with Pinto’s Auto Body Inc.