Each judge’s rank in the vicinage (shown in parentheses) is based on his or her overall score on a 1-to-10 scale, which is an average of the judge’s scores in all nine evaluative categories. Under each score is the quantity of survey responses received in that category.
Judge (Rank)
1.
Fairly weighs evidence and arguments
2.
Properly applies procedure and evidence rules
3.
Knowledgeable on substantive law
4.
Capable of handling complex cases
5.
Familiar with pleadings, briefs and record
6.
Skillfully fosters settlement when appropriate
7.
Moves proceedings and makes decisions promptly
8.
Courteous and respectful to litigants and lawyers
9.
Unbiased as to race, gender and party identity
10.
Overall Score
Roberto Alcazar (20)
5.55
5.42
5.34
4.57
5.57
5.41
5.10
6.46
7.33
5.64
71
71
71
69
70
69
72
71
69
Kathryn A. Brock (18)
7.62
7.15
6.84
6.04
7.88
6.61
6.34
8.91
8.88
7.36
142
141
141
140
142
127
139
141
138
Karen M. Cassidy (4)
8.72
8.82
8.82
8.83
8.80
8.18
8.56
8.86
9.13
8.75
124
124
123
123
123
120
123
124
120
Lisa F. Chrystal (11)
8.12
7.8
7.70
7.46
7.97
7.61
7.60
9.08
8.92
8.03
94
95
96
94
96
85
96
96
95
William A. Daniel (9)
8.42
8.08
7.66
7.20
8.00
8.11
7.44
9.43
9.44
8.20
89
88
88
84
87
80
87
87
84
Joseph P. Donohue (2)
8.92
8.95
9.09
8.98
9.06
8.91
8.92
9.52
9.57
9.10
65
66
64
63
65
64
65
65
65
Katherine R. Dupuis (10)
8.21
8.14
7.91
7.76
8.12
7.82
7.84
8.92
8.96
8.19
116
116
116
113
116
111
116
118
113
Douglas M. Fasciale (3)
9.19
9.13
8.99
9.03
9.10
8.55
8.91
9.33
9.40
9.07
78
78
78
75
77
73
77
79
78
Kenneth J. Grispin (1)
9.38
9.21
9.21
8.93
9.31
9.00
8.93
9.55
9.63
9.24
29
29
29
29
29
29
29
29
27
James C. Heimlich (15)
7.63
7.31
7.19
6.94
7.56
6.98
7.13
8.08
8.22
7.45
48
48
48
47
48
42
48
48
46
David J. Issenman (5)
8.49
8.57
9.03
8.67
8.37
8.34
8.46
8.97
9.16
8.67
103
102
101
100
102
102
102
106
102
Frederic S. Kessler (12)
8.06
7.63
7.84
7.37
8.53
7.48
7.13
8.23
9.07
7.93
31
30
31
30
30
29
31
31
29
John F. Malone (7)
8.31
8.21
8.24
7.98
8.37
7.64
7.58
9.18
9.05
8.28
100
99
101
97
100
92
97
101
100
Frederic R. McDaniel (14)
7.74
7.58
7.71
6.87
7.84
6.88
6.95
8.62
8.48
7.63
38
38
38
38
38
34
38
39
40
Robert J. Mega (6)
8.38
8.27
8.19
7.85
8.08
8.00
8.18
8.84
9.22
8.33
37
37
36
34
36
34
38
38
37
Scott J. Moynihan (8)
8.20
8.26
8.54
8.42
8.65
8.09
8.30
7.19
8.74
8.27
46
46
46
45
46
44
46
48
47
Stuart L. Peim (13)
8.20
8.17
8.32
7.82
8.05
7.10
7.21
8.07
8.26
7.91
41
41
41
39
41
39
42
42
42
Joseph P. Perfilio (19)
6.61
6.25
6.35
5.85
6.42
5.96
6.45
8.42
8.03
6.70
31
32
31
27
31
26
31
31
31
Jo Anne B. Spatola (16)
7.23
7.51
7.53
7.38
7.72
6.98
7.38
6.96
7.85
7.39
47
47
47
47
47
46
47
46
46
William L’E. Wertheimer (17)
7.20
7.35
8.07
7.86
7.66
6.94
7.89
6.40
7.14
7.39
184
184
184
180
183
176
183
188
180
AVERAGES
8.01
7.89
7.93
7.59
8.05
7.53
7.62
8.45
8.72
7.98