While recent U.S. Supreme Court precedent states that a search warrant must be obtained in order to retrieve a defendant’s cellphone-linked location data, that rule does not apply retroactively in the case of a man involved in a kidnapping scheme.

After rehearing argument in the matter, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit on Tuesday affirmed its previous denial of defendant Jay Goldstein’s motion to suppress his cell site location information (CSLI), reasoning Goldstein had no reasonable right to privacy.