New York Yankees great Alex ”A-Rod” Rodriguez is facing punitive damage claims stemming from a six-year legal battle with his ex-brother-in-law over a national multifamily partnership that went awry.

Constantine Scurtis claimed Rodriguez—who was married to Scurtis’ sister, Cynthia Scurtis, from 2002 to 2008—pushed him out of their real estate venture, denying Scurtis profits he claimed were due.