The First District Court of Appeals reversed a $3.2 million personal injury judgment granted to a cargo pilot forced into early retirement after a cow struck his vehicle on a state highway.

A16-page dissent accompanied the decision, challenging the majority’s willingness to disregard the role of the trial judge as factfinder, and the majority’s own interpretation of what constituted the defendants’ knowledge of the risk.

Is Landowner Liable for Wandering Cow?