Each judge’s rank in the vicinage (shown in parentheses) is based on his or her overall score on a 1-to-10 scale, which is an average of the judge’s scores in all nine evaluative categories. Under each score is the quantity of survey responses received in that category.
Judge (Rank)
1.
Fairly weighs evidence and arguments
2.
Properly applies procedure and evidence rules
3.
Knowledgeable on substantive law
4.
Capable of handling complex cases
5.
Familiar with pleadings, briefs and record
6.
Skillfully fosters settlement when appropriate
7.
Moves proceedings and makes decisions promptly
8.
Courteous and respectful to litigants and lawyers
9.
Unbiased as to race, gender and party identity
10.
Overall Score
Allison E. Accurso (7)
8.02
8.12
8.21
7.98
8.29
7.56
7.89
8.47
8.79
8.15
132
133
133
129
130
126
132
133
125
Paul W. Armstrong (14)
7.07
6.89
6.89
6.46
7.26
6.94
6.33
8.56
8.40
7.20
54
53
53
52
53
48
51
52
48
Ann Reynolds Bartlett (5)
8.30
8.32
8.48
8.11
8.42
7.86
7.67
8.76
9.02
8.33
90
90
90
88
90
83
88
91
88
Peter A. Buchsbaum (10)
7.85
7.64
7.78
7.33
8.04
6.97
7.43
8.37
8.92
7.81
135
134
132
125
133
116
133
134
128
Yolanda Ciccone (6)
8.12
8.17
8.13
8.22
8.34
7.90
8.42
8.40
8.85
8.28
180
182
181
175
181
168
179
179
175
Edward M. Coleman (8)
7.93
7.97
8.48
8.33
8.43
7.46
8.37
7.79
8.42
8.13
69
69
69
64
67
57
71
71
64
John J. Coyle Jr. (4)
8.39
8.25
8.25
8.17
8.26
8.38
8.35
9.10
9.27
8.49
97
97
97
93
95
95
93
94
88
Thomas H. Dilts (2)
8.73
8.75
9.05
8.74
8.81
8.34
8.76
8.76
8.94
8.76
132
130
130
128
129
124
131
132
127
Fred H. Kumpf (15)
6.53
6.31
6.10
5.51
6.70
5.93
6.71
7.81
8.47
6.67
128
129
128
121
129
113
126
128
121
Julie M. Marino (3)
8.6
8.68
8.61
8.47
8.66
8.4
8.15
9.04
9.15
8.64
97
95
95
91
94
88
96
95
92
Amy O’Connor (13)
7.60
7.30
7.07
6.42
7.43
6.97
6.95
8.84
8.85
7.49
81
81
83
81
81
79
81
81
80
Anthony F. Picheca Jr. (11)
7.86
7.70
7.25
6.85
7.49
7.29
7.24
8.51
8.68
7.65
56
53
55
52
53
48
55
55
53
John H. Pursel (1)
8.90
8.90
8.80
8.57
8.73
8.64
8.90
9.07
9.24
8.86
30
30
30
28
30
28
30
30
29
Robert B. Reed (12)
7.56
7.42
7.35
7.47
7.61
7.22
7.72
8.00
8.33
7.63
66
66
65
64
64
60
65
65
60
Stephen B. Rubin (9)
7.75
7.70
7.29
7.28
7.62
7.66
8.16
8.59
8.82
7.87
101
98
100
93
98
92
97
100
93
AVERAGES
7.95
7.87
7.85
7.59
8.01
7.57
7.80
8.54
8.81
8.00