X

Thank you for sharing!

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

Decided and Entered: January 11, 2007 500844 ________________________________ MAINES PAPER & FOOD SERVICE, INC., Appellant, v LOSCO GROUP, INC., Respondent. ________________________________ Calendar Date: November 15, 2006 Before: Peters, J.P., Mugglin, Rose, Lahtinen and Kane, JJ. __________ Hinman, Howard & Kattell, L.L.P., Binghamton (Linda B. Johnson of counsel), for appellant. Greene & Zinner, P.C., White Plains (Samuel D. Friedlander of counsel), for respondent. __________ Kane, J. Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Relihan Jr., J.), entered September 6, 2005 in Broome County, which, inter alia, granted defendant’s motion to vacate a default judgment entered against it. Defendant, the general contractor on a school reconstruction project, subcontracted with plaintiff to furnish, deliver and install food service equipment. Plaintiff completed the work contracted for and received payment from defendant in the amount of the agreed-upon price minus a 10% retainage fee which was provided for in the subcontract. Plaintiff thereafter commenced this action to recover the balance of the subcontract price and, when defendant failed to appear, took a default judgment against defendant. Supreme Court granted defendant’s subsequent motion to vacate the default judgment. Plaintiff appeals. We affirm, finding that defendant established both a reasonable excuse for the default and a meritorious defense (see Loris v S & W Realty Corp., 16 AD3d 729, 730-731 [2005]; Clark v MGM Textiles Indus., 307 AD2d 520, 521 [2003]). With regard to the issue of reasonable excuse, defendant submitted evidence indicating that it never received a copy of the summons and complaint, either from the Secretary of State or plaintiff. The Secretary of State, after receiving the summons and complaint from plaintiff, attempted to forward the pleadings to defendant in accordance with Business Corporation Law § 306 (b) (1). The United States Postal Service, however, despite having defendant’s correct mailing address, apparently mistakenly returned the pleadings to the Secretary of State. Thus, this is not a case where the defaulting party did not receive the summons and complaint due to its own failure to provide the Secretary of State with a proper current address (compare Crespo v A.D.A. Mgt., 292 AD2d 5 [2002]). In response to plaintiff’s assertion that it mailed a copy of the pleadings directly to defendant, defendant’s president averred that it had no notice of this action until plaintiff advised that a default judgment had been entered. The foregoing demonstrates that defendant’s default was not willful and there is no indication in the record that plaintiff has suffered any prejudice (see Dodge v Commander, 18 AD3d 943, 945 [2005]; Aaron v Carter, Conboy, Case, Blackmore, Napierski & Maloney, 12 AD3d 753, 754 [2004]). Turning to the issue of meritorious defense, the subcontract entered into by the parties contained a provision that expressly allowed defendant to withhold 10% of the fee owed to plaintiff until such time as the construction project was completed and accepted by the owner of the project, just as a 10% retainage fee was withheld from defendant by the owner pursuant to General Municipal Law § 106-b. Although some provisions of the subcontract are void and unenforceable, the provision relied upon by defendant is valid inasmuch as it merely fixes the time for payment and does not constitute an improper pay-if-paid restriction (see Welsbach Elec. Corp. v Mastec N. Am., 7 NY3d 624, 628 n 2 [2006]; West-Fair Elec. Contrs. v Aetna Cas. & Sur. Co., 87 NY2d 148, 153-155 [1995]). Defendant asserts that the owner has not yet accepted the project, so the final payment to plaintiff is not yet due. Such proof from defendant was sufficient for the purpose of showing a meritorious defense. Peters, J.P., Mugglin, Rose and Lahtinen, JJ., concur. ORDERED that the order is affirmed, with costs.

 
Reprints & Licensing
Mentioned in a Law.com story?

License our industry-leading legal content to extend your thought leadership and build your brand.

More From ALM

With this subscription you will receive unlimited access to high quality, online, on-demand premium content from well-respected faculty in the legal industry. This is perfect for attorneys licensed in multiple jurisdictions or for attorneys that have fulfilled their CLE requirement but need to access resourceful information for their practice areas.
View Now
Our Team Account subscription service is for legal teams of four or more attorneys. Each attorney is granted unlimited access to high quality, on-demand premium content from well-respected faculty in the legal industry along with administrative access to easily manage CLE for the entire team.
View Now
Gain access to some of the most knowledgeable and experienced attorneys with our 2 bundle options! Our Compliance bundles are curated by CLE Counselors and include current legal topics and challenges within the industry. Our second option allows you to build your bundle and strategically select the content that pertains to your needs. Both options are priced the same.
View Now
September 18, 2024 - September 19, 2024
Dallas, TX

Join General Counsel and Senior Legal Leaders at the Premier Forum Designed For and by General Counsel from Fortune 1000 Companies


Learn More
September 24, 2024
Chicago, IL

Women, Influence & Power in Law Awards honors women lawyers who have made a remarkable difference in the legal profession.


Learn More
September 23, 2024 - September 25, 2024
Chicago, IL

WIPL is the original global forum facilitating women-to-women exchange on leadership and legal issues.


Learn More

A prominent AV-rated Education Law firm seeks an associate with 5+ years experience. The role will primarily involve advice and counsel in ...


Apply Now ›

Associate attorney position at NJ Immigration Law firm: Leschak & Associates, LLC, based in Freehold, NJ, is looking for a full time ass...


Apply Now ›

Javerbaum Wurgaft, a large civil litigation firm with nine (9) offices, seeks: Plaintiff Personal Injury Attorney for Northern New Jersey of...


Apply Now ›