A three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on Thursday upheld a summary judgment ruling in favor of Kind LLC, the maker of nut-laden granola bars and other snack foods, in a multidistrict class action suit regarding Kind’s use of the words “All Natural” on its packaging.

Circuit Judges Steven Menashi, Eunice Lee and Sarah Merriam ruled that the definitions of “All Natural” as pleaded failed to create a triable issue of fact, and that the plaintiffs’ deposition testimony also failed to create a triable issue of fact.