Gwinnett County voters ousted embattled Superior Court Judge Katherine Schrader in favor of Deborah Fluker, with the challenger pulling in 59.2% of 47,289 votes to Schrader’s 40.8%, according to preliminary results.

Fluker’s outsized win comes despite being outspent nearly 2-to-1 by Schrader, who had to campaign for reelection even as pending criminal charges spurred her to step aside from her judicial duties for nearly a year.