Ontario’s highest court has overturned a decision awarding more than $340,000 to a Windsor, Ontario, man who claimed he suffered mental anguish after finding a dead fly in a bottle of water delivered to his home.

As a result of the decision by the Ontario Court of Appeal, Waddah (Martin) Mustapha must also pay Culligan of Canada Ltd. $30,000 in court costs, in addition to court costs from the original trial, which have yet to be determined.