Thank you for sharing!

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.
Dit-dit-dit-daaaah. Talk about a great hook! Three quick G’s and a long E-flat — they just don’t come any better than that. Step aside, Mick and Keith — the opening of Ludwig van Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony just could be the most memorable musical phrase of all time. During World War II, its suggestion of Morse code became the powerful symbol of “V for Victory.” GIs who didn’t know Schumann from shinola knew this was Beethoven and relished the irony of German music galvanizing the Allied effort to defeat the horrific murder machine that country had become. But that’s just the first five seconds. As for the rest, in nearly every poll, even of classical sophisticates, the Beethoven Fifth tops the list of favorites. Clearly, Beethoven crafted something powerful and universal that reverberates with ageless significance in every listener regardless of their depth of musical culture. In retrospect, we revere Beethoven for having ushered in the century of music which most classical fans enjoy the most. While Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart certainly was pushing in that direction (and might have broken through had he lived past 36), it was the bold harmonic and structural explorations of Beethoven that launched the Romantic era in music, in which personal feelings challenged the constraints of conventional form. While the Fifth isn’t Beethoven’s most innovative or influential symphony (the Third and Ninth compete for that honor) it did have a wealth of groundbreaking features: the first use of a trombone in symphonic music, variations built upon dual themes, two movements joined together, the reprise of an earlier passage in the finale and, most impressive of all, a single motif that unifies the entire work. Beethoven reportedly called his opening “Fate knocking at the door,” but nowadays that’s largely discredited as unreliable hearsay; as Beethoven’s posthumous fame grew, many associates tried to magnify their own significance by claiming special insights. But, as befits one whose genius lay in the abstract realm of music rather than a more specific art, Beethoven didn’t trivialize his creations with a single connotation. Even so, the entire work exemplifies the Romantic ideal of an expressive journey, not in the sense of telling a story but rather as an emotional catharsis. MIRACLE OF CONSTRUCTION “Fate” or not, the commanding opening figure pervades the entire work. The first movement is grim and resolute yet charged with constant conflict and energy as glimmers of hope swirl through a relentless storm. It’s a miracle of construction, with all the ideas firmly grounded in that first four-note phrase — even a lyric second theme rides atop and ultimately devolves into it. The focused intensity is relieved by a flowing set of variations, leisurely but with controlled surges of power. Next comes a resolute march, built largely upon the insistent rhythm of the opening motif and which descends into a hushed section of coiled tension and then explodes into the finale, an exhilarating shout of C-major triumph. In a masterstroke, Beethoven magnifies the effect by summoning again the tense portion of the third movement march and then repeating the triumphant explosion all over again. The work ends in a breathless coda built upon variants of the opening motif to pound home the permanence of the joyous destination. While Mozart may have written out masterpieces in final form right off the top of his head, Beethoven struggled over the Fifth for nearly a decade. Many early ideas and sketches found in his notebooks started out conventionally, with lengthy repetitions and standard harmonic progressions. As a great composer, Beethoven delved deeply into his material to explore and develop its full potential, and as an equally great editor, he constantly simplified and tightened it. In final form, the Fifth is a masterpiece not only of invention but also of concision. Unlike movies and novels we consider great but in which minor changes would be inconsequential, not a single note of the Fifth could be improved. But please don’t think of the composer who lavished so much devout care on perfecting his work as a pure soul whose rarified spirit had risen far above the venality of the rest of us mere mortals. Beethoven was all too human — he contracted to sell the Fifth to a wealthy patron for 500 florins (a considerable sum), but after collecting the first 350 turned around without apology or refund and sold the very same score to a publisher. But perhaps it was Beethoven’s intense humanity that enabled him to write in a style that appealed to real people, not just aristocrats. That, in itself, is an essential key to understanding Beethoven’s lasting appeal. Two centuries ago, classical music was wholly dependent upon the patronage of nobility. Public concerts were rare, and established professional orchestras unknown. The Fifth was given its world premiere Dec. 28, 1808, in a massive four-hour concert that consisted entirely of new major Beethoven works, including his Sixth Symphony, Mass in C, Fourth Piano Concerto and Choral Fantasia. By the time the Fifth rolled around that night, the audience was not only too exhausted to have paid much notice but also nearly frozen, as the hall was unheated and the winter bitterly cold. With only a single rehearsal by a pick-up ensemble for the entire program of unfamiliar and difficult music, the execution was a mess; at one point, things got so tangled that Beethoven had to stop and restart, a humiliation that the shivering players repaid. Not surprisingly, the world was hardly transformed by first hearing this fabulous creation; as the premiere was essentially an exercise in sight-reading, notions of sensitivity and interpretive feeling were well beside the point. Nowadays, we’ve made up for that with a huge variety of distinctive, highly polished and deeply expressive recordings that plumb the considerable depths of this amazingly rich work. Here are some favorites: Although Arturo Toscanini’s reputation as a classical speed demon is largely unwarranted, he does claim the fastest Fifth on records — a stunning concert of May 8, 1945, celebrating VE Day (on Music & Arts CD 753). Toscanini was a fervent anti-fascist, and the overthrow of Mussolini and Hitler overpowered his usual sense of proportion to produce a hair-raising distillation of his political emotions that clocks in at a breathless 26 minutes, 45 seconds. Nearly as thrilling are his two studio recordings-a fleet and streamlined 1953 LP (BMG 60255) and a richer and more complex 1939 set of 78s (BMG 60270). Politics also flavored the best of Wilhelm Furtwangler’s readings. The first was a 1943 Berlin concert (Music & Arts 4049) in which Furtwangler’s personal agony is frighteningly tangible as the vast pounding tympani and inflated dynamics of his wartime desperation battle the symphony’s intrinsic indomitable spirit. (Despite suspicions of collaboration for having remained in Germany throughout the war, Furtwangler was deeply conflicted and courageously endangered himself by working within the system to save dozens of lives.) A May 1947 concert (Music & Arts 789) marked his return to active musical life after his exoneration. Proceeding from a grimly powerful opening to an ecstatic outburst of victory, it symbolized not only Furtwangler’s personal odyssey from repression to freedom but the triumph of permanent culture over temporary politics. There’s also a remarkably noble 1954 Vienna studio set (EMI 69803) in which Furtwangler harnesses his former angst to animate a subtly shifting and superbly controlled overall flow. For the opposite extreme to Toscanini, Otto Klemperer, one of the stalwarts of German tradition, stretches his Fifths out to a glorious 40 minutes, both in a 1959 studio record (EMI 63357) and, to even greater effect, in a magnificent 1969 concert (EMI 66865). The result is like an athlete in slow motion, with power transmuted by surreal grace. Equally spacious is Glenn Gould’s playing of the Liszt piano transcription (Sony 52636), highlighted by an Andante of prayerful intimacy. A different sort of transcendence is achieved by Sergiu Celibidache (EMI 56521); consistent with his Zen beliefs, he strips the music of all rhetoric and presents it as a pure radiant abstraction. SPEAKING FOR ITSELF At this point you may well ask: Does music this great really require extensive interpretation to convey its treasures? No, it certainly doesn’t and indeed most conductors, perhaps humbled before Beethoven’s genius, let the Fifth speak largely for itself. Among many others, Fritz Reiner (RCA 68976), Carlos Kleiber (DG 447 400), Pierre Monteux (London 443 479) and Herbert von Karajan — any of four (!) versions on EMI or DG — all present magnificent playing and a satisfying balance of energy and control, drive and repose. A fascinating alternative is one of the “authentic instrument” renditions, which use the smaller orchestras, lower tunings, less powerful instruments and wind- and brass-heavy balances of two centuries ago in an attempt to recreate a performance that Beethoven’s audiences would have recognized. It’s not a mere gimmick — Beethoven wrote the Fifth for the purpose of being performed, with a specific sound image in mind. But rather than settling our historical curiosity, the results raise an interesting question — despite careful scholarship to emulate the original sound, they all sound so different, from the warmth, leisurely pace and subtle blend of the Hanover Band (Nimbus) to the furiously driven Orchestre Revolutionnaire et Romantique (Archive). Which of these would Beethoven have chosen as the most valid? Ironically, he might have been utterly indifferent; by the time he finished the Fifth, he was largely deaf and so perhaps conceived the work largely in the abstract after all! In reviewing several dozen Fifths for this column, I was struck by two realizations. First, even after such intensive and repeated exposure, I’m still as enthralled by the work as ever. Second, I’ve yet to hear a single record, even by an unknown orchestra and conductor, that’s without interest. And that, perhaps, is the strongest proof of Beethoven’s genius — this is a work of limitless depth and matchless inspiration that constantly challenges and transcends personal taste and trends. Peter Gutmann is a partner at the Washington, D.C., communications firm Pepper & Corazzini and can be reached at [email protected]. Music articles by the author are posted on his Web site at www.classicalnotes.net.

This content has been archived. It is available through our partners, LexisNexis® and Bloomberg Law.

To view this content, please continue to their sites.

Not a Lexis Advance® Subscriber?
Subscribe Now

Not a Bloomberg Law Subscriber?
Subscribe Now

Why am I seeing this?

LexisNexis® and Bloomberg Law are third party online distributors of the broad collection of current and archived versions of ALM's legal news publications. LexisNexis® and Bloomberg Law customers are able to access and use ALM's content, including content from the National Law Journal, The American Lawyer, Legaltech News, The New York Law Journal, and Corporate Counsel, as well as other sources of legal information.

For questions call 1-877-256-2472 or contact us at [email protected]


ALM Legal Publication Newsletters

Sign Up Today and Never Miss Another Story.

As part of your digital membership, you can sign up for an unlimited number of a wide range of complimentary newsletters. Visit your My Account page to make your selections. Get the timely legal news and critical analysis you cannot afford to miss. Tailored just for you. In your inbox. Every day.

Copyright © 2021 ALM Media Properties, LLC. All Rights Reserved.