A Philadelphia judge has upheld a $5 million verdict rendered over a 1-year-old’s death allegedly due to liver failure from an overdose of Infants’ Tylenol, in part because the judge said the makers of the over-the-counter drug filed a 29-point statement of matters in violation of Rule 1925(b).

McNeil-PPC Inc. has appealed Judge Annette M. Rizzo’s decision in Dunson v. McNeil-PPC Inc. to the Pennsylvania Superior Court.