In his summer of discontent, there were few days of undiluted glory for attorney general Alberto Gonzales and 17 July was no exception. Just six weeks before he resigned, Gonzales stood before hundreds of federal prosecutors and investigators in the US Department of Justice’s Great Hall to celebrate the fifth anniversary of the department’s Corporate Fraud Task Force and declare victory over white-collar corruption.

But the white-collar crime news that day was not dominated by Gonzales’ recitation of notches on his prosecutorial belt. Instead, the headlines focused on a federal judge in New York who dismissed indictments against 13 former KPMG executives; a very pointed rebuke to the Justice Department for some of the more aggressive tactics used by federal prosecutors over the past five years.