Opinion Allowing Sentimental-Value Damages Appealed
The Medlens' dog Avery.
A defendant has asked the Texas Supreme Court to reverse a first-of-its kind opinion that allows a family to recover damages for the "sentimental value" of a dog. In a petition for review, the defendant alleges the 2nd Court of Appeals' opinion in the case creates a new loss-of-companionship cause of action for a pet's death and therefore should be reversed on public policy grounds. The dog was named Avery.
TOP STORIES
- Lawyer Sued Over YouTube Video Can't Fight Back With Anti-SLAPP Law
- Firm Alleges Defendants Misappropriated Trade Secrets, Privileged Info
- Special Report: Litigation and E-Discovery
- Commentary: Why PIRAC? Tips for Motion Practice in Travis County
- Citizens May Intervene in Case Over Red Light Camera Contract
- The Strongest Law Firm Brands in the Land
- Discipline
SPONSOR SPOTLIGHT
Decision of the Day
City of Dallas v. Stewart
(Tex. 01/27/2012)
In this takings case, the city of Dallas challenges the court of appeals' holding that the Dallas Urban Rehabilitation Standards Board's nuisance finding could not be preclusive because of a brief delay between the nuisance finding and the house's demolition. A system that permits constitutional issues of this importance to be decided by an administrative board, whose decisions are essentially conclusive, does not correctly balance the need to abate nuisances against the rights accorded to property owners under our constitution. In the context of a property owner's appeal of an administrative nuisance determination, independent court review is a constitutional necessity. The court of appeals' judgment is affirmed on different grounds. Texas Supreme Court, No. 09-0257, 01-27-2012.
Other Publications From Texas Lawyer
Stories from the Law.com Newswire
- U.K. Moves 'No Win, No Fee' Litigation Reforms to 2013
Legal Week
- Goodwin Procter Grabs 4 IP Litigators From Paul Hastings
The Recorder
- Davis Wright Launches Calif. Real Estate Practice With DLA Laterals
The Recorder
- Minter Ellison Takes Steppe Forward With Mongolia Office Launch
The Asian Lawyer
- Hogan Lovells Equity Capital Markets Chief Quits to Join Latham's London Arm
Legal Week
Blogs
- Tex Parte Blog
- Morning docket: Judge delays Fort Hood shooting trial, former Fort Worth lawyer sentenced to 10 years and more.
- Field goal: Haynes and Boone partner joins stage crew at Super Bowl halftime show to meet Madonna.
- Adult film case: Judge orders attorney to pay $22,000 in attorney's fees, attorney asks 5th Circuit for stay.
- See the Full Blog >>
- Work Matters
- Well-rounded RIP: Why counsel should focus on strengths instead of trying to do it all.
- Symmetry smarts: The role of symmetry in attractiveness and leadership potential.
- See the Full Blog >>
Video
Alan Waldrop and David Chamberlain discuss both sides of expedited trials: mandatory and voluntary.
TL Podcasts
- Supreme Court Sides with Ex-Worker in Anti-Retaliation Case, Labor and Employment Law, by Michael P. Maslanka
- Objecting to the Admission of Harmful Evidence, Personal Injury and Civil Trial Law, by Quentin Brogdon
- The Insured's Right to Select the Policy That Maximizes Coverage, Insurance Law, by Ernest Martin
- See the Full List of Podcasts >>
Survey Participation
- Verdicts and Settlements: If you've worked on a big case and want to see the verdict or settlement reported, send the details to Texas Lawyer by filling out this form.
![]() |
- I Like Being a Lawyer: Billable hours. Demanding bosses and clients. Student loans. A lack of civility. We all know the cons of being a lawyer, but what are the pros? Tell us the top five reasons you like being a lawyer.
SPONSOR SPOTLIGHT
TexLaw Insider
The ability to recover attorneys' fees may be the deciding factor in whether or not to file a lawsuit and almost always plays a critical role in the decision to settle or try a case. Texas Lawyer’s How to Recover Attorneys' Fees in Texas is a complete, step-by-step guide for practicing attorneys to help them win and defeat attorneys' fees claims at trial. For more information or to order your copy, click here. 












