Law.com
  • News
    • Newswire
    • Large Firm
    • Corporate Counsel
    • Technology
    • Washington
    • Supreme Court
    • International
    • Legal Blog Watch
    • Video
  • Publications
    • The American Lawyer
    • Corporate Counsel
    • Law Technology News
    • The National Law Journal
    • New York Law Journal
    • New Jersey Law Journal
    • Connecticut Law Tribune
    • The Legal Intelligencer (PA)
    • Daily Business Review (FL)
    • Delaware Law Weekly
    • Daily Report (GA)
    • The Recorder (CA)
    • Texas Lawyer
    • Publication E-Alerts
    • More Publication Sites
  • Legal Research & Directories
    • Books Online
    • Smart Litigator
    • ALM Experts
    • Verdict Search
    • Court Reporters
    • Legal Dictionary
    • LegalTech® Directory
    • Newsletters
    • More Directories
  • Surveys, Lists & Rankings
    • Amlaw 100
    • NLJ 250
    • Global 100
    • The A-List
    • ALM Legal Intelligence
    • Surveys
    • More Lists & Rankings
  • lawjobs.com
    • Post a Job
    • Find a Job
    • Post a Resume
    • The Careerist Blog
    • News & Views
  • LawCatalog Store
    • Books Online
    • Best-Selling Books
    • Books
    • Directories
    • E-Newsletters
    • Magazines
    • Newspapers
    • Newsletters
    • Surveys
    • Research Services
    • Webinars
    • Events
  • CLE & Events
    • CLE Center
    • ALM Events
    • LegalTech
    • Virtual LegalTech
    • Insight Legal Events
    • Webinars
Home
 
Article
  • email
  • twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • alert
  • rss

Law.com Home > Supreme Court Justices Consider Courts' Role in Arbitration

Font Size: increase font decrease font

Supreme Court Justices Consider Courts' Role in Arbitration

By Tony Mauro All Articles 

The National Law Journal

April 27, 2010

  •    
  •    
  •    
  •      
 

Related Items

  • Supreme Court Strengthens Arbitration in Labor Case Ruling

The U.S. Supreme Court's pro-arbitration trend appears intact after oral arguments Monday in a key case asking whether it should be courts or arbitrators themselves who rule on the enforceability of an arbitration agreement.

Consumer groups say the outcome of the case, Rent-A-Center, West v. Jackson, could determine whether courts have any role in overseeing arbitration clauses in labor agreements, which they see as biased toward employers. Business groups, for their part, don't want courts second-guessing what they see as validly agreed-upon arbitration agreements.

"If companies win, this really will be a watershed case," said Deepak Gupta, an attorney for Public Citizen, which asserts that arbitrators rule against consumers 94 percent of the time.

During the past two decades, the high court has generally ruled to strengthen the enforceability of arbitration agreements. On Monday, few justices appeared eager to change that trend, though several seemed to believe that courts should play some role in checking especially egregious agreements. Dallas lawyer Robert Friedman of Littler Mendelson, representing the business side of the case, urged the Court to continue its practice of "sending very, very complicated matters to the arbitrator" rather than the courts.

But Ian Silverberg of Hardy & Associates in Reno, Nev., who argued for the employee, cast doubt on the impartiality of arbitrators -- so much so that, when Justice Antonin Scalia asked whether an arbitrator could enforce with impunity a "Shylock contract" that allows an employer to "exact a pound of flesh," Silverberg implied that could happen because there is "no adequate review."

Silverberg represented Roberto Jackson, an account manager at a Nevada branch of Rent-A-Center, a rental company. Jackson, who is African-American, claimed he was not promoted because of his race. His employment agreement called for the dispute to go to an arbitrator.

Jackson filed suit in federal court in Nevada nonetheless, arguing the agreement was one-sided and "unconscionable," and therefore could not be enforced. The trial court dismissed the case, finding that, under the arbitration agreement, even the question of its enforceability went to the arbitrator. But the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled (pdf) for Jackson, holding that the issue of unconscionability should be decided by the courts.

On Monday, Justice Stephen Breyer appeared sympathetic to the employee, asking whether, as a matter of contract rather than arbitration law, an unconscionable agreement warranted court review.

But Chief Justice John Roberts Jr. and Scalia seemed more favorable to employers, with Scalia citing a U.S. Chamber of Commerce brief (pdf) contending that unconscionability claims in courts had snowballed. The brief was written by Donald Falk of Mayer Brown's Palo Alto, Calif., office.

In response, Silverberg cited a brief filed on behalf of "some of the most prestigious arbitrators in the country" who sided with the employee and said courts have a "vital role in maintaining the fairness of the arbitration process." The brief by Kevin Russell of Howe & Russell in Bethesda, Md., said that if issues of arbitrability are not reviewed by courts, arbitration won't have the benefit of precedential court decisions, which help to increase public trust in its fairness.



Subscribe to The National Law Journal

You must be signed in to comment on an article

Find similar content

Firms mentioned

    
  • Littler Mendelson
  • Mayer Brown
  • Littler Mendelson
  • Mayer Brown

Companies, agencies mentioned

    
  • U.S. Supreme Court
  • Rent-A-Center
  • Public Citizen
  • Hardy & Associates
  • U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals
  • U.S. Chamber of Commerce
  • Howe & Russell
  • Rent-A-Center
  • U.S. Supreme Court
  • Public Citizen
  • Hardy & Associates
  • U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals
  • U.S. Chamber of Commerce
  • Howe & Russell

Key categories

    
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution

Most viewed stories

    
  1. Court Officials Seek to Reform Process of Naming Acting Justices
    •      
  2. Donovan Criticizes Secret Payoff to Lopez Victims
    •      
  3. The 2013 Am Law 100
    •      
  4. Prolific ADA Plaintiff Faces Nemesis in Harassment Suit
    •      
  5. Real Estate Lawyers Target Closing Vendors
    •      
lawjobs.com

TOP JOBS

MORE JOBS

POST A JOB

From the Law.com Network

Taking the Reins of Legal Department Operations

In-House Law: Now in 3-D!

Simpson Helps Yahoo, Tumblr Connect for $1 Billion Deal

Kasowitz Benson Launches in Los Angeles

Contrite Companies Can Win Forgiveness in Bribery Cases
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Plaintiffs Want to See Toyota's 'Crown Jewels'
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Collaboration Is Key to Defending Cyberattacks

Stanford Law Builds on Role as Legal Tech Incubator

Prolific ADA Plaintiff Faces Nemesis in Harassment Suit

Ullyot Exit Closes Chapter for Facebook

Rothstein Bankruptcy Trustee Files New Reorganization Plan
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Fla. Bar Wants Disbarment for Former Judge
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Appellate Division To Roll Out Electronic Case Filing System

Court Limits Liability for Injury Or Death of One Invited To Help
  •      
    • Subscription Required

The Affordable State-Specific Practice Solution
Available in NY, NJ, PA and CT editions - research, draft and prepare even the most complex cases with ease.

Court Officials Seek to Reform Process of Naming Acting Justices

NYC Defends Police Department's Use of Stop-and-Frisk

Immigrant Investor Program Gets Watchful Eye

Parties Ordered to Hire Neutral Expert to Probe Facebook

Law Schools Are Looking Beyond LSATs, Says Mich. Dean

Is Freezing Your Eggs the Solution?

Water Warriors: Local Governments Bring Pollution Suits
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Sanction Reversed; Filing of Sexually Explicit Chat OKd
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Brooks Looks To Political Ally For Criminal Defense

Attorney Fee Hearing in Waffle House Sex Case Heats Up
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Corporate Bribery Case Part Of National Trend
  •      
    • Subscription Required

Court Continues To Grant Lawyers Fraud Immunity
  •      
    • Subscription Required

The Law.com Network
  • ADVERTISE

law.com

  • Tour the New Site
  • Newswire
  • Special Reports
  • International News
  • Lists, Surveys & Rankings
  • Legal Blogs
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Site Map

alm national

  • The American Lawyer
  • The Am Law Litigation Daily
  • Corporate Counsel
  • Law Technology News
  • The National Law Journal

alm regional

  • Connecticut Law Tribune
  • Daily Business Review (FL)
  • Delaware Law Weekly
  • Daily Report (GA)
  • The Legal Intelligencer (PA)
  • New Jersey Law Journal
  • New York Law Journal
  • GC New York
  • The Recorder (CA)
  • Texas Lawyer
  • The Asian Lawyer
  • Focus Europe

directories

  • ALM Experts
  • LegalTech® Directory
  • In-House Law Departments at the Top 500 Companies
  • Top Rated Lawyers
  • The American Lawyer Top Rated Lawyers
  • The American Lawyer Legal Recruiter's Directory
  • Corporate Counsel Top Rated Lawyers
  • The National Law Journal Leadership Profiles
  • National Directory of Minority Attorneys
  • Go-To Law firms of the Top 500 Companies

books & newsletters

  • Best-Selling Books
  • Publication E-Alerts
  • Law Journal Newsletters
  • LawCatalog Store
  • Law Journal Press Online

research

  • ALM Legal Intelligence
  • Court Reporters
  • MA 3000
  • Verdict Search
  • ALM Experts
  • Legal Dictionary
  • Smart Litigator

events & conferences

  • ALM Events
  • LegalTech®
  • Virtual LegalTech®
  • Virtual Events
  • Webinars & Online Events
  • Insight Information

reprints

  • Reprints

online cle

  • CLE Center

career

  • Lawjobs
About ALM  |  About Law.com  |  Customer Support  |  Reprints  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms & Conditions |  ALM User License Agreement