A California appellate court found that a reasonable person would not jump to the same conclusions as a plaintiff who alleged a tangerine juice-maker fraudulently branded its product as “No Sugar Added,” implying that all other competing juices do contain added sugar and are less healthy.

California’s Second District Court of Appeal Thursday affirmed the dismissal of the case against plant-based food producer Califia Farms, defended by Sheppard Mullin Richter & Hampton’s Sascha Henry in Los Angeles.