In a rare self-reversal, the New Jersey Supreme Court has overturned its five-year-old ruling that permitted appeals courts judges to use their own judgment in reviewing decisions made by trial judges regarding the admissibility of evidence in criminal trials.

The court on Wednesday issued a unanimous decision, State v. S.S., overturning its 2012 decision in State v. Diaz-Bridges, which had been decided by a bare 3-2 margin.