Judge Peter Doyne has presided over countless foreclosures, but the case of an Ecuadorean immigrant who claims he was duped into taking a mortgage he couldn’t afford “stands out from the others.”

Doyne denied summary judgment in U.S. National Bank Association v. Montesdeoca, finding the bank presented a prima facie case for foreclosure but debtor Oscar Montesdeoca presented sufficient evidence to suggest genuine issues must still be decided.