X

Thank you for sharing!

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER Appeal from a judgment of the County Court of Chemung County (Rich Jr., J.), rendered June 24, 2016, which revoked defendant’s probation and imposed a sentence of imprisonment. JUSTICE PRESIDING STAN PRITZKER In July 2015, after pleading guilty to disseminating indecent material to minors in the second degree, defendant was sentenced to six months in jail, to be followed by 10 years of probation. In January 2016, defendant was charged with violating several terms of his probation. Following a probation violation hearing, County Court found that the People had established a violation, and the court therefore revoked defendant’s probation and sentenced him to a prison term of 1 to 3 years. Defendant appealed, and we agreed with his argument that, under the circumstances presented, County Court did not fulfill its statutory duty to conduct a competency hearing pursuant to CPL 730.30 (4) (170 AD3d 1327, 1328 [2019]). We therefore withheld decision and remitted the matter to County Court for a reconstruction hearing evaluating defendant’s mental capacity at the time of his violation of probation hearing (id. at 1329). A reconstruction hearing was held, following which County Court (Baker, J.) found that, if a competency hearing had been held in advance of defendant’s probation violation hearing, there would have been a sufficient basis upon which to conclude that he was competent to stand trial. However, following that decision, the County Court of Oswego County (Hafner Jr., J.) issued an order granting certain CPL article 440 motions by defendant, vacating his conviction for disseminating indecent material to minors in the second degree and the sentence imposed thereon, dismissing the underlying superior court information and directing that the matter be sealed pursuant to CPL 160.50. The People agreed to this relief. As the People concede, given that defendant’s conviction for disseminating indecent material to minors in the second degree has been vacated, along with the sentence imposed thereon inclusive of defendant’s term of probation, any alleged violation of that probation is necessarily also a nullity (see CPL 160.50 [3] [f]; 160.60; People v. Anonymous, 34 NY3d 631, 637-638 [2020]; see e.g. People v. O’Brien, 190 AD2d 1097, 1097 [1993]; People v. DeFrancesco, 136 AD2d 560, 560 [1988]; People v. Bliss, 17 AD2d 767, 767 [1962]).1 Thus, this appeal challenging said violation must be dismissed as moot (see People v. Myers, 154 AD3d 1000, 1001 [2017]). Defendant’s appellate counsel urges this Court to vacate County Court’s finding of a violation of probation, rather than dismiss this appeal as moot, due to concerns over implications that this violation may have on a sentence being served on an unrelated federal conviction. We certainly appreciate appellate counsel’s concern and his zealous advocacy regarding this issue; however, defendant has already been afforded the relief he requests. To that end, County Court vacated defendant’s underlying conviction and sentence and sealed all records pursuant to CPL 160.50. Further, CPL 160.60 provides that, “[u]pon the termination of a criminal action or proceeding against a person in favor of such person, as defined in [CPL 160.50 (2)], the arrest and prosecution shall be deemed a nullity and the accused shall be restored, in contemplation of law, to the status he [or she] occupied before the arrest and prosecution.” Inasmuch as the “status [defendant] occupied before the arrest and prosecution” (CPL 160.60) is that of an individual who has not been found to have violated probation, that violation of probation is a nullity. Finally, the cases cited by defendant in support of his requested relief are inapposite because, in those cases, the defendants were appealing their underlying convictions and requesting that the convictions and sentences be vacated, based upon American Libs. Assn. v. Pataki (969 F Supp 160 [SD NY 1997]; see e.g. People v. Cepero, 164 AD3d 1465, 1466 [2018]; People v. Burgess, 54 AD3d 870, 870 [2008], lv denied 11 NY3d 895 [2008]). Here, defendant’s appeal is from the finding of a violation of probation rather than from the conviction for which he was originally sentenced to probation, which County Court has already vacated. Egan Jr., J.P., Lynch, Clark and Colangelo, JJ., concur. ORDERED that the appeal is dismissed, as moot.

 
Reprints & Licensing
Mentioned in a Law.com story?

License our industry-leading legal content to extend your thought leadership and build your brand.

More From ALM

Premium Subscription

With this subscription you will receive unlimited access to high quality, online, on-demand premium content from well-respected faculty in the legal industry. This is perfect for attorneys licensed in multiple jurisdictions or for attorneys that have fulfilled their CLE requirement but need to access resourceful information for their practice areas.
View Now

Team Accounts

Our Team Account subscription service is for legal teams of four or more attorneys. Each attorney is granted unlimited access to high quality, on-demand premium content from well-respected faculty in the legal industry along with administrative access to easily manage CLE for the entire team.
View Now

Bundle Subscriptions

Gain access to some of the most knowledgeable and experienced attorneys with our 2 bundle options! Our Compliance bundles are curated by CLE Counselors and include current legal topics and challenges within the industry. Our second option allows you to build your bundle and strategically select the content that pertains to your needs. Both options are priced the same.
View Now

New York Legal Awards 2021

October 13, 2021
New York, NY

The New York Law Journal honors attorneys and judges who have made a remarkable difference in the legal profession in New York.


Register

General Counsel Conference East 2021

September 22, 2021 - September 23, 2021
New York, NY

GCC East addresses General Counsel trends in regulatory, data protection, tech management, legal operations, and leadership.


Register

New Jersey Legal Awards 2021

September 23, 2021
Virtual, NJ

New Jersey Law Journal honors lawyers leaving a mark on the legal community in New Jersey with their dedication to the profession.


Register

Trusts & Estates Administrative Paralegal

Hackensack, New Jersey, United States

COLE SCHOTZ P.C. TRUSTS & ESTATES ADMINISTRATION PARALEGAL- NEW JERSEY, NEW YORK OR FLORIDA OFFICE: Prominent NJ based law firm with m...


Apply Now ›

Attorney - Sr. Contracts Specialist - IT

REMOTE, New York, United States

ATTORNEY/TEMPORARY/FULL-TIME:   Wonderful opportunity to work with the health care industry during these very important times!&nbs...


Apply Now ›

Immigration Attorney

New York, New York, United States

A midsize law firm has an immediate opening for an immigration attorney.  The ideal candidate must have a minimum of three years of exp...


Apply Now ›

JAVERBAUM WURGAFT HICKS

09/20/2021
NJLJ Web

JAVERBAUM WURGAFT HICKS mourn the passing of our Co-Founding Partner, collegue, and friend.


View Announcement ›

BARTON GILMAN LLP

09/14/2021
CLT Web

Barton Gilman Expands Into Connecticut


View Announcement ›

BARTON GILMAN LLP

09/14/2021
TLI Web

Barton Gilman LLP is excited to announce that its expansion into Philadelphia


View Announcement ›