Editor’s Note: This article has been updated to reflect a Correction.

Turned 76 in 2010
(certification not available)

Abraham G. Gerges, Kings
Charles J. Thomas, Queens
Martin Schneier, Kings
Robert J. Hanophy, Queens
David S. Ritter, Orange
Timothy J. Flaherty, Queens
David Stadtmauer, Bronx
Eugene L. Nardelli, Appellate Division, First Department
Elizabeth W. Pine, Appellate Division, Fourth Department
Fred T. Santucci, Appellate Division, Second Department

Justices who have been
certificated until Dec. 31, 2012

Age 70:

Bert A. Bunyan, Kings
Timothy J. Drury, Erie
Bernard J. Fried, New York
Emily Jane Goodman, New York
William A. Kelly, Rockland
Edward A. Maron, Nassau
Salvatore Martoche, Appellate Division, Fourth Department
Barbara F. Newman, Bronx
Robert L. Nahman, Queens
Richard L. Price, Bronx
Barry Salman, Bronx
Alice Schlesinger, New York
Albert Tomei, Kings
Penny Wolfgang, Erie

Age 72:

Peter Fox Cohalan, Suffolk
Anthony J. Cutrona, Kings
Joseph G. Golia, Queens
William J. Kent, Suffolk
William P. Polito, Monroe
Lewis Bart Stone, New York
Sidney F. Strauss, Queens
Louis B. York, New York

Age 74:

Caesar D. Cirigliano, Bronx
Nicholas Colabella, Westchester
William M. Erlbaum, Queens
Anita R. Florio, Appellate Division, Second Department
Anthony I. Giacobbe, Richmond
Herbert Kramer, Kings

SOURCE: Office of Court Administration

ALBANY – Boxing papers and mementos she has accumulated over the last quarter century in the courthouse she considers “her second home,” Elizabeth W. Pine this week contemplated her forced retirement from the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, seat she has held since 1985.