The insurer for the city of Stockbridge, Georgia, paid more than $1.7 million in April to settle claims by a local barbecue joint owner that he had been targeted for official harassment after he refused to comp a city councilman’s $60 bill.

Now the city’s insurer says it’s having some trouble of its own with the owner of BBQ Masters after mistakenly overpaying him $1 million, which it would very much like returned.