What happened on the New Haven Green during a march and rally on Dec. 9 has appropriately been decried by political and faith leaders of all backgrounds as “the desecration of the Hanukkah menorah.” But after bearing witness to such a deeply painful incident, is it possible to nonetheless find some solace in the events that followed?

At a march and rally in New Haven organized by American Muslims for Palestine CT (AMPCT), We Will Return Palestine (WWR), University of Connecticut Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP), and Yalies 4 Palestine (Y4P), a man, his faced covered, approached the New Haven Green menorah, which has been displayed publicly every year during Hanukkah for the last 42 years.