X

Thank you for sharing!

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.

With the increasing use of arbitration as an alternative to full-blown litigation, the risk of a conflict of interest by an individual arbitrator has grown. This risk can be mitigated significantly by the use of comprehensive and exhaustive investigative due diligence, background checks, and investigative link analysis to determine the connections between an arbitrator and one of the parties or counsel in the arbitration. This investigation will invariably help to weed out connections or a hidden conflict that might taint the fairness of the proceeding or raise the appearance of bias. Sources of potential arbitrators, such as the American Arbitration Association, are required to disclose any potential conflict of interest in disclosure statements submitted to the parties well in advance of the commencement of the arbitration. This process is helpful to the attorneys in deciding on an arbitrator, but certainly neither all-inclusive nor the most reliable way to vet an arbitrator. Often, arbitrators may not even realize that the conflict of interest exists before the arbitration commences, or they may not believe the interest is material or considered significant enough to rise to a conflict and thus may not disclose it. The Second Circuit Court of Appeals holds that " ‘evident partiality’ . . . will be found where a reasonable person would have to conclude that an arbitrator was partial to one party to the arbitration." Morelite Construction Corp. v. New York City District Council Carpenters Benefit Funds, 748 F.2nd 79, 83 (2nd Cir. 1984). The Second Circuit has further stated that "[a]n arbitrator who knows of a material relationship with a party and fails to disclose it meets Morelite‘s ‘evident partiality’ standard, which is that ‘a reasonable person would have to conclude that an arbitrator who failed to disclose under such circumstances was partial to one side.’ " Applied Industrial Materials Corp. v. Ovalar Makine Ticaret Ve Sanayi, A.S., 492 F.3rd 132, 137 (2nd Cir. 2007). Furthermore, where an arbitrator has reason to believe that a conflict of interest may in fact exist, he or she has an obligation to investigate the conflict, or must disclose his or her reason for believing there might be a conflict and their basis for not investigating. In substance, the case law requires arbitrators to disclose material relationships with the parties to an arbitration, and if necessary, they have a burden to investigate whether a conflict exists. A proper investigation and a comprehensive vetting of an arbitrator is therefore axiomatic. The lawyer should consider the use of outside private investigators to assist with this task. Some investigators can conduct this task in a manner that the lawyers could not. For instance, in a recent FINRA hearing setting, my company, Confidential Security & Investigations (CSI), was asked by the plaintiff’s attorney representing the investor who had lost his investment to vet an arbitrator who seemed biased against his client. When background checks were conducted and subsequent link analysis of the findings had occurred, it was uncovered that the arbitrator and a principal at the adversary’s law firm had previously worked at the same small law firm together and were current members of the same country club board. In light of this, deeper diving was performed and it was learned that the arbitrator failed to disclose on his disclosure statement several other connections to the opposing counsel that, in totality, were very significant and showed evident conflict. The plaintiffs’ lawyer, armed with this information, was able to prevail and have the arbitrator recuse himself from the arbitration, and the arbitration had to start anew with a newly agreed-upon arbitrator. Some private investigators have the skills, resources, and capabilities to vet the background of arbitrators and get access to data that the attorney cannot. The task of vetting the arbitrator should include the following process:

ALM Legal Publication Newsletters

Sign Up Today and Never Miss Another Story.

As part of your digital membership, you can sign up for an unlimited number of a wide range of complimentary newsletters. Visit your My Account page to make your selections. Get the timely legal news and critical analysis you cannot afford to miss. Tailored just for you. In your inbox. Every day.

Copyright © 2017 ALM Media Properties, LLC. All Rights Reserved.