| The Bottom 10: The 10 Worst Performers of 2003 | ||||
| Company or Group | 2003 Complaint Ratio |
2003 Ranking |
2002 Ranking |
2001 Ranking |
| 1 Leucadia | 18.78 | 49/49 | 49/50 | 50/51 |
| 2 Interboro | 2.19 | 48/49 | 47/50 | 10/51 |
| 3 Infinity | 1.46 | 47/49 | 46/50 | 48/51 |
| 4 Clarendon | 1.02 | 46/49 | 50/50 | 49/51 |
| 5 Great American | 0.7 | 45/49 | 46/50 | 48/51 |
| 6 Safeco | 0.64 | 44/49 | 38/50 | 47/51 |
| 7 Fairfax Financial | 0.52 | 43/49 | � | � |
| 8 Mercury Casualty | 0.47 | 42/49 | � | � |
| 9 Lumbermens | 0.46 | 41/49 | 27/50 | 18/51 |
| 10 AIG | 0.38 | 40/49 | 41/50 | 46/51 |
| The Big 10: The Largest Auto Insurers in New York | ||||
| Company or Group | 2003 Ranking | 2003 Complaint Ratio |
2002-2003 Average Premium (In Millions) |
Market Share |
| 1 Allstate | 32/49 | 0.22 | $1,698.80 | 16.60% |
| 2 Berkshire-Hathaway (GEICO) | 38/49 | 0.35 | $1,422.60 | 13.90% |
| 3 State Farm | 15/49 | 0.08 | $1,329.00 | 13.00% |
| 4 Progressive | 19/49 | 0.14 | $660.20 | 6.40% |
| 5 Travelers | 27/49 | 0.19 | $611.60 | 6.00% |
| 6 Liberty Mutual | 20/49 | 0.15 | $458.00 | 4.50% |
| 7 AIG | 40/49 | 0.38 | $447.40 | 4.10% |
| 8 White Mountains | 36/49 | 0.33 | $375.70 | 3.70% |
| 9 New York Central | 12/49 | 0.08 | $366.00 | 3.30% |
| 10 Nationwide | 26/49 | 0.18 | $335.00 | 3.30% |
| The Big Ten | $7,674.30 | 75.10% | ||
| Total (all companies, including those with less than $10 million premiums) | $10,237.10 | 100.00% | ||
| ( New York Law Journal, January 2005) | ||||
