Breaking and associated brands will be offline for scheduled maintenance Friday Feb. 26 9 PM US EST to Saturday Feb. 27 6 AM EST. We apologize for the inconvenience.


Thank you for sharing!

Your article was successfully shared with the contacts you provided.
Note: Conventional wisdom has it that the children of influential people avoid the military. Matthew Scalia, the 31-year-old son of Justice Antonin Scalia, has not. Army Capt. Scalia, the sixth of Justice Scalia’s nine children, served for 13 months in Iraq with the 1st Armored Division. His tour was extended when insurgent uprisings broke out in Sadr City, Karbala, and Najaf. Recorder affiliate Legal Times spoke to Scalia by e-mail after his return to Germany in July. Scalia, a 1995 graduate of the U.S. Military Academy, said emphatically that he was glad he went to Iraq. “If it weren’t for being apart from my wife and daughter (who was 6 months when I left), I’d say there were no regrets. I am more impressed with the American military than ever before. The maturity expected of and displayed by a 20-year-old soldier is that of a 40-year-old.” What did his family think? Scalia said, “My family (especially my father) has been extremely supportive of me and my military career. Of course they didn’t want me to go to Iraq, but they were proud. They supported my sense of duty; the nation was at war and the Army had a mission to do.” Asked about his future plans, he said, “The Army has treated me very well, and I love it. It is the soldiers and my peers that make it all worthwhile. . . . So far I plan on making it a career, but as numerous mentors have advised me before, I’ll stay in as long as I’m having fun. But there’s little more fun or rewarding than serving.” Following is an essay Scalia wrote further detailing his experiences in Iraq. –Tony Mauro I deployed to Iraq in May ’03 as an infantry company commander in the 1st Brigade, 1st Armored Division. We had been preparing for months and thought we would be part of the ground war, so most of our training focused on that. However, when the ground war ended in April, we quickly refocused our training to scenarios we were more likely to face, including crowd control, searches, traffic control points and convoy operations. We left not knowing how long we would be gone. Our division commander told us to expect it to be one year. Due to our experiences in the Balkans with shorter deployments, few of us thought it would actually be that long. We flew into Kuwait and spent two weeks receiving our equipment, conducting additional training (including weapons fire, basic Arabic terms, and Iraqi culture) and acclimating to the hot desert. Camp Udari, our home for those two weeks, was miserable. The heat and sand storms were unbearable; we were anxious to move north. On May 27, 2003 (my second wedding anniversary), my brigade convoyed over 500 kilometers to Baghdad. It was a 24-hour movement that took us through the open desert and tiny villages of the countryside and into the capital city full of palaces and monuments. The contrast was striking. I was surprised by the number of huts that stood in the middle of nowhere, and the number of Iraqis walking on the dirt road with no water and no village in site. How did these people survive? Conversely, it was obvious that Baghdad was once a beautiful city. There were wide streets, many lined with trees, and small parks and beautiful mosques throughout. However, streets and sidewalks were in disrepair and buildings were dirty. It appeared not to be as a result of the war, but rather years of neglect. My company’s movement ended at the Al Shaheed, or Martyr’s Monument. Saddam Hussein built it in 1989 for the Iraqis killed in the Iran-Iraq war. Like our Vietnam Memorial, the walls are engraved with their names. The names are so numerous they cover the walls on the inside and outside. My company spent two days at the monument as our division got situated. We then moved to Baghdad Tourist Island and began preparing for our new mission. My infantry company was cross-attached to an armor battalion, a normal procedure to combine the strengths of armor and infantry. The task force, TF 1-37 Armor (Bandits) — consisting of my infantry company, two armor companies, a headquarters company, mortar platoon and scout platoon — was responsible for the northeast portion of Baghdad. My company specifically had Zone 22, which included two neighborhoods, Al Beida and Hay Ur. Al Beida was a fairly affluent neighborhood with a mixture of Sunni and Shi’a Muslims and Christians. Crime was not as much of a problem there. Hay Ur was largely Shi’a and bordered Sadr City (formally Saddam City, where Saddam stuffed three million Shi’a to live in poor housing). Here crime was definitely a problem. At first we spent most of our time in Hay Ur handling petty criminals. As we received more intelligence on insurgent activities through the summer, more of our missions were raids on suspected insurgent homes in Al Beida. The crime in Hay Ur diminished dramatically. Our mission was twofold: Defeat remnants of the old regime, while assisting the Iraqi people in rebuilding their country. Each unit had specific sites that required constant protection from looters or insurgents. My company maintained a force at all times at an electrical station and a United Nations food distribution warehouse. Because of its central location, Iraqis came to the electrical station for assistance, to report crimes or to provide intelligence (including locations of suspected Ba’ath sympathizers). On a typical day, scores of people came to our gate complaining of the lack of electricity, reporting crimes or telling us where we might find Saddam. Because we were responsive to problems, my platoons developed a very strong relationship with the residents. I have many memories of patrolling through the streets receiving smiles and “thumbs-up,” from the children especially. One of our first missions in early June was to establish a neighborhood advisory council. The NAC was supposed to be a cross-section of the community, with members of different religions, social standing, education, occupation and sex. Commanders were allowed to select them, but most of us were encouraged to hold neighborhood meetings to allow residents to vote. The meetings for Al Beida and Hay Ur are some of my best memories. Each meeting had thousands of people show, mostly men, but many women as well. Their enthusiasm and interest was incredible. It was the first time in over 30 years that Iraqis could provide input into their representation. Although my soldiers had some difficulty dealing with the noisy crowds, we knew we were participating in history. Many of us also thought of the creation of our own country and how this might have been comparable. I spent many hours with the NACs in the following months. The weekly meetings averaged over three hours. We worked together to fix the neighborhoods’ problems, including security, distribution of propane (their main fuel for cooking and heating), youth services, area beautification and garbage collection. We prioritized use of reconstruction money and fixed up schools, clinics, and youth centers. After a couple of months, many new businesses and restaurants opened; the gunfire we had heard all night, every night when we first arrived became rare; and many schools reopened. I developed some strong friendships with NAC members. Though some had less-than-noble intentions, many were truly committed to improving Iraq. One close friend, whom I saw just before Christmas when he came to my new base to give me a present for my daughter, was killed in his home in front of his son for being a member of the council. This was a threat they all felt. The schools in my zone were in terrible condition. We spent hours removing ordnance. Most had broken windows, desks and bathrooms, and had not been painted in years. In fact, I was told nothing at all had been done to them in years. Seeing the numerous palaces that Saddam had built since the Persian Gulf War, I couldn’t help but conclude that the sanctions had failed. As the summer of 2003 progressed, we conducted fewer and fewer routine patrols. We were making room for the new Iraqi defense forces to take over. Some of my soldiers trained facility protection guards (who eventually replaced us at the electrical station and food warehouse) and the Iraqi Civil Defense Corps. The Baghdad police force was also growing. All of these forces enabled us to focus our efforts on the insurgents, who had been increasing their attacks. In September, I left my infantry company to take command of the Brigade Headquarters Company in Baghdad. Although it was good for me professionally, I hated to leave the men I had been with for 13 months. I was so impressed by their conduct and discipline. Under extremely stressful situations, 19- and 20-year-old soldiers were maintaining their composure and not succumbing to frustration or anger. It is a testimony to Americans and the high standards we set for ourselves. Throughout my 14 months in Baghdad, I had plenty of interaction with Iraqis. The interpreters we hired became great friends. Because they came to know us so well, they were also helpful in our public relations. They saw all the efforts we took to help the country and greatly appreciated it all. Yet most of them chose to keep their jobs a secret from their neighbors. Many quit because of threats to them or their family. But others stayed, enduring the threats of improvised explosive devises, mortars, and ambushes along with us. I truly wish that the average American could meet the average Iraqi, because he would realize that we are needed and wanted over there. My time in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom was an incredible experience. Not in my wildest dreams did I ever imagine I would lead an infantry company into a combat environment. I am extremely proud of my service and my units’ performance. However, it is the families at home who deserve the greatest recognition. They had to deal with not knowing what their soldiers were enduring. They had to live in the same homes with all the memories. It is difficult to imagine the loneliness my wife felt, and even more difficult to imagine that I will likely deploy again. It is not just soldiers who enlist and re-enlist; it’s families too.

This content has been archived. It is available through our partners, LexisNexis® and Bloomberg Law.

To view this content, please continue to their sites.

Not a Lexis Advance® Subscriber?
Subscribe Now

Not a Bloomberg Law Subscriber?
Subscribe Now

Why am I seeing this?

LexisNexis® and Bloomberg Law are third party online distributors of the broad collection of current and archived versions of ALM's legal news publications. LexisNexis® and Bloomberg Law customers are able to access and use ALM's content, including content from the National Law Journal, The American Lawyer, Legaltech News, The New York Law Journal, and Corporate Counsel, as well as other sources of legal information.

For questions call 1-877-256-2472 or contact us at [email protected]


ALM Legal Publication Newsletters

Sign Up Today and Never Miss Another Story.

As part of your digital membership, you can sign up for an unlimited number of a wide range of complimentary newsletters. Visit your My Account page to make your selections. Get the timely legal news and critical analysis you cannot afford to miss. Tailored just for you. In your inbox. Every day.

Copyright © 2021 ALM Media Properties, LLC. All Rights Reserved.