Failure to give proper notice to a homeowner under New York’s foreclosure fraud law is a defense that can be raised at any time, a Brooklyn appeals court has ruled in a decision of first impression at the state appellate level.

In dismissing a foreclosure suit against homeowner Alan Silver, a panel of the Appellate Division, 2nd Department, held that the lender seeking to foreclose had the burden of showing strict compliance with the state’s Home Equity Theft Prevention Act.