Virtually every lawyer is familiar with the rules versus standards trade-off. Rules provide clearer guidance but sometimes produce bad results (i.e. “loopholes”). Standards provide more flexibility but at the cost of diminishing ex ante notice. For a high level court such as the Supreme Court, the degree of specificity with which to announce a doctrine—and, correspondingly, the amount of discretion to leave to lower courts to develop the doctrine in future cases—typically involves the basic tradeoff between ex ante notice and ex post flexibility.
YOUR COMPLIMENTARY 15-DAY LAW.COM TRIAL HAS ENDED.
Subscribe now to continue reading →