A company that helped produce two songs for Alecia Moore—Pink—more than a decade ago cannot collect the royalties it says it is owed, a Manhattan appeals panel ruled Tuesday.

In a unanimous, unsigned opinion, Appellate Division, First Department Justices Peter Tom, Helen Freedman, Rolando Acosta, Richard Andrias and Rosalyn Richter wrote that the original royalties agreement between the singer and predecessor to her current record label Sony did not allow for enforcement of the claim.