Nineteen years was too long to wait to prosecute a murder charge, a judge has ruled in throwing out a 2007 indictment for a 1988 Bronx shooting.

Supreme Court Justice Troy K. Webber (See Profile), sitting in the Bronx, dismissed an indictment charging Raed Ayyash with second-degree murder, finding that the prosecution’s 19-year delay in bringing it denied Mr. Ayyash his due process rights to prompt prosecution.