Editor’s Note: Most weeks, news articles in The National Law Journal are written and reported by our staff writers. In this issue, however, we’re devoting significant space to a story authored by a reporter from a new contributor: ProPublica, the Pulitzer Prize-winning nonprofit news organization that produces investigative journalism in the public interest. It’s the first time the NLJ has partnered with ProPublica, but we’re in good company: The New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post and several others have featured the high-quality journalism produced by the ProPublica team. For more information about ProPublica or to read other investigative articles produced by its reporters, please visit www.propublica.org.

The government’s case for keeping the Guantánamo Bay prisoner locked away seemed airtight. He had confessed to overseeing the distribution of supplies to al-Queda fighters battling U.S. forces in Afghanistan, even describing the routes where pack mules hauled the packages.